From Creativity to Success
Doing Our Best to Help Our Clients Succeed
Jeremy Ben-David, Founder, Managing Partner
Our World is not perfect. Far from it. But it is the one in which we go to sleep every night and wake up to in the morning, both literally and figuratively. As members of the society in which we live, our responsibility is to help, to contribute. We travel within society, shop and work among its members so, at a bare minimum, as beneficiaries of all that society has to offer, our contribution is, if nothing more, a quid pro quo.
However, when I consider the successes that Israeli inventors and startup companies have had over the past several decades, not just in terms of quality but in sheer numbers, it is clearly driven by more than self-interest. Some people have an internal, creative drive to solve problems; in our profession, we call them âinventorsâ.
And surrounding the problem solvers, there is an entire ecosystem for building products which embody the inventions, and to develop the attractive end-products which will find their way into peopleâs homes, offices and other spaces. And then you have the brand identity designer, those who picture how their company and its products can be displayed most prominently in the digital storefront of the modern era, with millions of competing products advertised on millions of websites, all struggling to gain attention. And all of the above jobs, and people that do them, form part of every team tasked with placing innovation in the market.
And this is where we come into things, as IP attorneys. Our challenge is to use the tools at our disposal to help our clients to the best of our abilities.
A quote attributed to Vince Lombardi, the legendary coach of the Green Bay Packers in the 1960âs, is âPerfection is not attainable, but if we chase perfection we can catch excellence.â
Sports consultants are often brought on board at an early stage so as to set out a training program in advance of the season that lies ahead. All too often, however, they are consulted only after the season has started, and this delay will almost certainly require the consultant to make the best decisions in a less than perfect situation.
Similarly, in a perfect world, our clients would reach out before they have publicized their âideaâ, or started regulatory or other stages at which disclosure is required to outside players, such as distributors, product designers and others. However, there will invariably be a delay in bringing us on board, if for no other reason than everyone is busy doing their âthingâ, and that includes the different members of the development and marketing team.
So, we, in turn, do our best to help in less than ideal circumstances. If portions of a system have been disclosed, we look to see how other parts of the system which may still be on the drawing board, can be leveraged as patentable inventions. If we are lucky, final product design may still be under wraps, so that design protection can be under way before exposure. In some cases, if products have been disclosed, our advice may be to change their design. This is often the case when a product is to be imported into Israel, but after it has been marketed overseas for several years.
Often times, a trademark or logo is set in stone, long before we are consulted. Itâs then up to us to suggest solutions which, while not guaranteeing perfection, reflect our best understanding as to how we can best protect the clientâs interests. This may even include advice concerning matters that clients will mostly not ask us about, such as domain name registrations or IP notices for websites. But here too, we need to think out of the box.
The second half of the Lombardi quote above is âif we chase perfection we can catch excellence.â I think that itâs difficult to define either perfection or excellence in our field. After all, if our clientsâ competitors never challenge them or never force our clients to enforce their IP rights, on whom or what is that a reflection?
Does it mean that no one found our clientsâ offerings particularly interesting or valuable? Or is it due to the sterling job that we have done in both advising and in being to implement an IP strategy so that competitors simply stay away? In most cases, we will never know.
In conclusion, therefore, I would say that when we go to sleep at night and wake up in the morning, itâs less a matter of wondering whether we have achieved excellence, but whether we have done our best in bringing our considerable experience to bear for the benefit of our clients and, by extension, for society.
In short, our need to invest maximum effort must always be at the forefront, no less than the inner creative drive possessed by every single person in the innovative ecosystem. An ecosystem indeed; a âsocietyâ of which we are proud to be an integral part.